The Readers' Cafe: Is the narrator unreliable?

Question

  • J Philpott

    J Philpott

    Newbie: +10

  • 18 Sep 13:38

    The narration of this book is certainly interesting, our narrator seems to use excessive and often misplaced punctuation, a prevalence of simple sentences and fragments that really negatively impacts the flow of prose. I was wondering whether these devices were intentional in portraying a psychological disorder, or just an indictment of a relatively inexperienced author.

    3 Answers

    • David L Atkinson
      1

      David L - No-vel prize: +892

      18 Sep 18:36

      Who the hell do you think you are? Criticism is fine and I would expect feedback that would help me improve and no I am not psychologically disturbed but I am a new author. God forgive you for being too cowardly to be out there to receive responses to your negative tirades!

    • Ross Kitson
      1

      Ross - No-vel prize: +716

      18 Sep 21:03

      David- I wonder if ‘J’ is actually implying the main character has a psychological disorder- hence the use of punchy, short sentences and lots of exclamation marks etc. ( I assume he/she means something like OCD or personality disorder, which given he is half accountant-half vigilante might be plausible!).
      Take your point about wrong place for a review though- didn’t know profiles could be private either.

    • David L Atkinson

      David L - No-vel prize: +892

      19 Sep 12:49

      Aoppreciate your input Ross thinking about it you could be correct. I wrote this almost two years ago and was trying to stress the OCD nature of Steele’s personality. I also recall trying to emulate, to a degree the style of Raymond Chandler in that first section. Perhaps I was being a little over sensitive! Thank you.

    Your Answer

    Identify helpful responses for other users by clicking ‘I like’ and both you and the author of the response will get extra reputation points.

    Administrators

    Share

    Followers